Skip to content
ArticleEducation5 min read

Should we give credit to this customer?

A new customer wants to pay in sixty days. Saying yes might win the account; saying no might lose it. What a business owner weighs, the checks to run in India, and why the answer is about you, not the customer.

Written by the GullyFuture team. How we write these

Start reading
Illustration of Indian professionals reviewing financial worksheets and a calculator

Illustrative image · GullyHR

Explore this page3 sections

Overview

This is the decision-lab question students find hardest, because both answers look reasonable and the information you would want is not available. A promising new customer wants credit terms. The salesperson wants to say yes. The person who has to make payroll is less sure.

Here is what an owner is thinking about while the student is deciding.

At a glance

Key takeaways

  • Credit is a loan; decide it the way a lender would, not the way a salesperson would
  • The question is not whether they will pay, but whether you can survive if they pay late
  • Find out how they pay everybody else before you find out how they pay you
  • Start small; the first order tells you what the fifth will be like
  • Put terms in writing before you deliver; in India, the law gives a micro or small supplier limits and interest rights, but only if the paperwork is in order
  • Losing a customer who will not pay on time is not a loss

Read the article

The first reframe is the one that changes the whole conversation. Extending credit is lending money. When you deliver goods worth two lakh and agree to be paid in sixty days, you have lent that customer two lakh, unsecured, at no interest, and their promise to repay is the invoice. A bank would want to know a great deal before doing that. Small businesses do it on the strength of a good meeting.

The second question is about you, not them: can you afford to be wrong? If this customer pays ninety days late, or not at all, what happens to your business? For a company with a cash reserve and a wide customer base, a late payment is an irritation. For a company where this order is a large share of the month's revenue, it is a salary run. The same customer is a reasonable risk for one business and a reckless one for the other, and the decision depends more on your position than on their character.

The third is due diligence, which good owners do and students do not think to. How does this company pay its other suppliers? You can ask: suppliers talk to each other, and a company that is slow with everyone is not going to be fast with you. How long has it existed? Who owns it? You can check that its GST registration is active on the public GST portal, and look up its company records on the Ministry of Corporate Affairs site. Does it have the kind of customers that pay it on time, so that it can pay you? Is the person promising sixty days the person who authorises payments, or a salesperson on their side making a promise on behalf of a finance department they have never met?

The fourth is structure, because the choice is not simply yes or no. You can say yes to a smaller first order, at shorter terms, and extend as they prove out. You can ask for part payment in advance. You can offer a small discount for payment on delivery and see whether they take it, which tells you something about their cash position. You can put a credit limit on the account so that a late payment stops further supply automatically, rather than leaving you to have that conversation. These are all easier to start with than to introduce after a loss.

The fifth is paper. Agree the payment period in writing, in a purchase order or contract, before you deliver, and invoice the day the work is accepted. In India this matters beyond good practice. If you are a micro or small enterprise, section 15 of the MSMED Act caps the payment period at 45 days from acceptance when there is a written agreement, and at 15 days when there is not, and section 16 provides for compound interest at three times the Reserve Bank of India's bank rate if a buyer is late. So a customer who asks you for sixty days is asking for more than the Act allows, if you are in that group. Whether to insist is a commercial judgement, but you should know your position when you decide. If you take a cheque, remember that a cheque that is dishonoured for insufficient funds gives you a separate legal route under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, which has its own notice deadlines, so ask an advisor early.

The sixth is the hardest for students and the clearest for owners: a customer who will not pay on time is not worth having, however large the order. Revenue you cannot collect is not revenue. It is work you did for free, plus the cost of financing it. The smaller customers who pay on the day keep a business alive while the large account is still being chased.

So the answer is rarely a flat yes or no. It is: yes, to this much, on these terms, in writing, after these checks, and we will see how the first invoice goes. That is not caution for its own sake. It is what lending money responsibly looks like, and it is what this decision actually is.

TopicsFinanceSales

Want to work on this with other people?

This is covered in a free community session. We run them for colleges, companies and groups when they ask.

No session is scheduled right now. Ask for one and we will email you.